1989: Fred Elkins, Gary Lehman, Denny Engler, Chuck Wiedman

​

1990: Chuck DePew

​

1991: Stan Perry*, Bernie Rickman, Red Foster, Van Smith, John Elkins

​

1992:

​

1993-2003: Hall of Fame Not Active

​

2004: Closed for Renovations

​

2005-2007: Hall of Fame Not Active

​

2008: Richard Poe, Edsel Musser*, Jerry Ladd, Jim Amstutz*, Hank Lower, Tony Smith, Randy Palmerton, Van Smith was recognized again for his help bringing back the Hall of Fame, Hargus Mullins*, Dick Roberts*, Willie Nelson*, John Grimm*, Duke Mullins, Lloyd Gearhart, Gary Hancock, Gaylord Parr*, David Anspaugh, Jack Landis Jr, Kenny Henderson, Larry Harpe, Clarence Schmuck

​

2009-2012: Hall of Fame Not Active

​

2013: Dick Markle (Margo), Bill West, Dale Miller*, Gerry Rumsey, Jr. Curtis, John Gearhart, Angie Roy

​

2014: Joe Ellert, Scott Moyer, Henry Dowker, Melvin “Cap” Straw*

​

2015: Roseanne Cook, Al Cook Jr*, Jennie West Sevits, Larry Zimmerman*, Don Sattison, Larry Henderson, Darwin Wolfe, Dave Robson, Blaine Miller*, Jeff Shelmadine*, Jim* & Mary Benson, Junior Gould, Captain Ron

​

2016: Mike Kline, Delos Penland, Eugene Terry, Lee Harpe, Ron Everidge, Tom Weidman, Jasper Case, Heather Margo

​

2017: Roger Petre, Doug Musser, Shirley Miller, Bob Psurny, Milburn Elkins

​

2018: Dave Nester Bud Grogg, Jeff Schaeffer, Todd Gearhart, Frank "Hacksaw" Snedaker, Forrest Demuth

​

2019: “Lighting” Lloyd DePew, Frank Anspaugh, Randy Pippenger, Bill McClanahan

​

2020: Ray Curtland, Rick Rinehart, Larry Patrick, Rob Jowsay, John Moonen, Tom Barto

​

2021: Richard "Dangerous Dick" Willms, Dick Musser, Steve Asztalos, Steve Minich Sr, Tom Blackburn

​

2022: NOT ACTIVE

​

2023: Rick Everidge, KC Spillers, George Anspaugh, Tommy Cook

​